Getting Ready for Steam Bending Wood

Shop built steam generator.
Shop built steam generator.

It will soon be time to start steam bending some of the parts we’ve been fabricating over the past few weeks.  See The Board Stretcher a.k.a. The Scarf Joint.  The keel will need to be bent to the curve of the bottom.  At least the forward part of it will be.  The aft 8 feet is supposed to be “straight as a string”.  Also, the inner chines will be bent into their chine landings on the frames of the boat.  And the lower transom bow will be bent to an 8 ft. radius curve per the original design drawings.  To get ready for this, I needed to build some very specific equipment.

The steam generator pictured at the beginning of this post is a nice design I got from Don Danenberg’s excellent book, The Complete Wooden Runabout Restoration Guide.  The main tube is a piece of 2 inch black iron pipe fitted with a heating element for a commercial water heater in the bottom end.  Note the electric cord running to the bottom of this unit.  Off the main tube, there’s a secondary tube, to which a sight glass is plumbed.  The sight glass let’s you monitor the water level so the heating element doesn’t run dry.  Water is supplied through a garden hose to the bottom, and regulated by a gate valve to maintain a constant water level.  This is easier to do than it might sound as the secondary tube calms the water level fluctuation caused by boiling at the heating element.  Steam is delivered through a piece of automotive heater hose attached to a nipple at the top of the primary tube.

Needless to say, you don’t want this unit to hold pressure.  And you want to make very sure you have it properly grounded.  It gets hot– 207 degrees by my measurement at the external of the primary tube near the heating element.  Hot steam, water and electricity can be a bad mix if not managed well.  I always keep a close eye on this piece whenever I’m using it.

Steam bending wood allows the wood grain to follow the curve of the finished piece, making for a much stronger part than if you were to simply cut a curved piece out of a straight board, thereby cutting across the grain at the ends of the curve.  Also, it’s much more economical.  Most lumber comes in straight pieces.  You waste much less by bending a straight piece to the curve you want.

When we steam bend wood, we use the heat of steam to soften the cell walls and the lignin in the wood structure (the natural glue that holds the wood cells together).  According to Webster’s dictionary, lignin actually makes up one-third to one-fourth the weight of wood, and after cellulose,  it is the most abundant organic compound on earth.

Once the wood cools, the lignin re-solidifies and the wood retains the curve without wanting to spring back to its original shape.  The water in the steam does not add water to the wood.  It’s just a way of transferring heat to the wood.  The rule of thumb is to cook the wood 1 hour for each inch of thickness.  Then take it out and see if it feels rubbery like it will bend in to the shape you want it to.  If not, put it back in and cook it some more.

Soaking and steaming box
Soaking and steaming box

We’ll need a box for soaking wood before bending, which can double as a steam box.  So, I put together a box out of 2x lumber that is 18′ 1″ long, 9-1/2″ wide, and 13″ deep.  This should accommodate all the pieces for this boat and future projects as well.  The box is lined with 6 mil plastic from the local hardware store, which can be removed when it’s used as a steam box.

 

 

 

 

The new keel, made of white oak, will need to soak for at least 2 weeks prior to steaming.
The new keel, made of white oak, will need to soak for at least 2 weeks prior to steaming.

The Board Stretcher a.k.a The Scarf Joint

Finished Scarf Joint
Finished Scarf Joint

What do you do when you can’t get lumber long enough to fill the need?  You go get the board stretcher!  Any neophyte woodworker has heard that one.  But the board stretcher I’m referring to really does exist.  It’s called a scarf joint.

Boatbuilders have been scarfing together lumber for a long time.  It’s a method of joining two boards so they have continuous sides as if the two boards have grown together to form one long board.  Before the days of the great glues we have today, the scarf joint was made by overlapping the boards with a long diagonal cut, and then pegging a backing block to the joint.  But I’m using epoxy.  And if done properly, the glued scarf joint is stronger than the wood fibers themselves, obviating the need for a backing block.

In this case, I’m scarfing together two planks to make a blank that is 16 ft. long by 6 inches wide by 1-1/2 inches thick.  That’s a serious piece of white oak!  But it needs to be, it’s the backbone of the boat.

So I start with an 8 ft and a 10 ft plank.  The scarf joint will be a diagonal overlap at a 12:1 ration.  This means that since the planks are 1-1/2 inches thick, the joint will be 18 inches long.  The joint needs to be so long in order to provide plenty of faying (glue-able) surface.  The more faying surface, the stronger the joint.  A structural joint like this one requires a 12:1 ratio.

1. Lining out the scarf cut on the edge of the board.
1. Lining out the scarf cut on the edge of the board.

I first line out the part of the board that will be cut away.  Look closely in the picture at left, and you’ll see the diagonal line I’ve drawn on the edge of the board.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

2. Boards stacked ready for planing.
2. Boards stacked ready for planing.

Then I stack the two boards on top of each other, offsetting them so I can make one long slanted cut with the power plane at the angle I want.  I finish the cut with the hand plane to make for a good fit.

 

Finished scarf cut.
3. Finished scarf cut.

 

 

 

4. Scarf joint wet out with epoxy.
4. Scarf joint wet out with epoxy.

 

 

 

 

Then wet out the glued surfaces with straight epoxy.  This lets some of the epoxy soak into the pores of the wood so the joint won’t be starved of glue.  Then slather on a nice thickened mixture of epoxy and clamp, leaving overnight for it to partially cure.

 

5.  Clamped scarf joint.
5. Clamped scarf joint.

When the joint is set, but the epoxy is still “green”, it’s time to plane it down to the finished thickness and clean up the joint.

 

 

 

6.  Laying out the outline of the finished keel on the new blank with a batten.
6. Laying out the outline of the finished keel on the new blank with a batten.

Then lay out the outline of the new blank from measurements taken from the old keel.  Since the edges are a curved taper, they have to be lined off with a batten as shown in the photo.

 

 

 

Finally, the blank is cut out on the bandsaw.  And there it is.

7.  The finished blank is cut out on the bandsaw.

7. The finished blank is cut out on the bandsaw.

The next step is to cut the rabbet (the groove along each edge where the bottom planking rests.  That’s another story…

Visit from an Old Friend

African Mahogany (Khaya Ivorensis)
African Mahogany (Khaya Ivorensis)

A couple of weekends ago my old college roommate and his wife came for a visit.  When I asked Mack what he wanted to do, he said “I want to go to the Boatworks!”  When presented with such unbridled enthusiasm, I’m not one to hesitate.  I had the perfect two-man job in mind–hossing a bunch of lumber around and re-sawing planks for the boat.  17 ft. boards of African Mahogany aren’t exactly light.  A second set of hands really does speed things along.

So we started with planing one face of the boards and soon discovered that the knives in the planer were dull and needed changing.  We managed to break two Craftsman torx drivers in the process (I have been of the opinion for a while now that Craftsman tools are not what they used to be).  But our friend Derek at the local Sears tool department had us back in business in no time.  We got the wood planed, but not resawed.  That was a task for another day. As you can see in the photo, I did manage to get some of this lumber resawed and planed down later.  The 1/2 inch planks will be used in the boat.  The 6/4 (thicker) planks on bottom have yet to be re-sawn into a usable thickness.  One more step to go on those.

Mack is still the great thinker that he always was, and we enjoyed talking over  old ideas and new.  It was good to see you Mack.  And thanks for the help!

New Chrome

Chris Craft Bow Light fresh from the re-chroming shop
Chris Craft Bow Light fresh from the re-chroming shop

I just got some of the chrome bits back from the re-chroming shop.  Nothing boosts your excitement like seeing shiny parts and imagining what the boat will look like with them on it.  This bow light replaces the old, un-authentic one that came with the boat.

This is the bowlight that was on the boat when I got it.
This is the bowlight that was on the boat when I got it.

The old one was not original with the boat.  As a matter of fact, it didn’t even have the red and green lenses on the correct sides.  The new light shown here was bought used, and then sent to a re-chroming shop.  It looks so much better now–practically new!  Can’t wait for the day when this light is needed to do a little night-time cruising!

Remove the Bottom

Bottom removed
Bottom removed

Removing the bottom is a pretty straightforward procedure.  With the proper tools, it doesn’t take much time at all.  It can be done in a day.

Screw heads exposed by abrading the bottom with a wire rope wheel
Screw heads exposed by abrading the bottom with a wire rope wheel

The basic procedure is to abrade away the wood at each screw head, and back out the screws in the  main frames, auxiliary frames, keel and chines.  The other screws, in the intermediate frames, and those holding the inner planking to the outer planking, can remain.

The trick is to get all of the screws you need.  Invariably you will miss a few that will show up when you get the pry bar out to take the bottom off.  Be patient and don’t tear anything up.  Just keep taking them out til you get them all.  Then the half bottom lifts off, easy as pie!

Exposed screw heads, port bow
Exposed screw heads, port bow

Each half of the bottom can be lifted off as a unit and saved for later review.  The planks on one side can be taken off individually to be used as patterns for the new bottom.

Two bottom halves on the shop floor
Two bottom halves on the shop floor

The tool of choice for abrading the wood at each screw head is a 4-1/2 inch grinder with a wire rope wheel.  As you might imagine, this destroys the old bottom planks.  So you can only do this if you’re not preserving the old bottom planks.  But why would you be replacing the bottom if you weren’t going to use new wood?  Some would argue that you should preserve as much of the original planking as possible, but I can’t see the logic behind putting back 60 year old, tired wood.  We’re replacing all the planking and bottom frames with new wood.

 

Dust tent with air filtration device
Dust tent with air filtration device

As you might imagine, going after all the screw heads with a grinder will stir up quite a bit of dust.  So the first step was to rig up a tent around the boat to contain that dust.  I didn’t want it going all over the shop.  I was able to set up my tent so that it enclosed one of my air filtration devices, so I could filter out a great deal of the dust that I generated.

Finished with bottom removal
Finished with bottom removal

I also wore a tyvek suit and a respirator during this operation.

 

 

 

Level It, Measure It, Build a Scaffold

A laser level is a real time-saver when setting up the boat.
A laser level is a real time-saver when setting up the boat.

Now that the boat is upside down (a major accomplishment–check out how we did it in the post labelled “Roll Her Over“), the next step is to get it plumb and level.  Now let me just pause here and say, that plumb and level means absolutely plumb and level.  Any inaccuracy here will compound itself over the course of the project because there will be countless times when you need to determine if something is level or not.  If you can just plop a spirit level on it, that simplifies the measurement considerably.  If you have to resort to stringing up string lines every time you have to take a measurement, it takes a lot longer.  So get it dead level now.

So what does plumb and level mean?  Well remember in Plans, I said I had gotten a copy of the lines drawing for this boat?  The load water line on those plans tells you where the boat should theoretically float when loaded.  So that line is the one you need to draw on the boat and then get it level.  It doesn’t matter that the boat is upside down.  Level is level.  Then level the two corners of the transom.  When you have done that, the stem should be plumb (i.e. at an angle of 90 degrees) to the ground.

Now a laser level greatly simplifies this task.  Before these nifty instruments were affordable for the average boat shop, one resorted to a water level to get the boat level and plumb.  Builders used it to level buildings as well.  It’s a fine tool.  Look it up on Wikipedia!  Anyway, projecting a level laser line on the hull is a lot easier, so that’s what I used.

A straightedge reveals a hook in the bottom.
A straightedge reveals a hook in the bottom.

Once that’s done, you can determine how close your boat is to the original design.  This boat was very close.  The worst the keel was off was 1-1/16″ low at about station 4.  That was a combination of the chine and the keel being a little low–each about 1/2″.  The width was within 3/4″ over the whole length of the boat.  And there was about a 1/2″ concavity in the planing surface of the bottom, called a hook because it slows the boat down.  That’s not bad for a 60 year-old!  It took a good deal of time to determine this, but it was worth it.

A tape measure shows exactly where the strut palm and the hole for the rudderpost are located.
A tape measure shows exactly where the strut palm and the hole for the rudderpost are located.

Then of course there are alot of other things to measure and document–like where all the holes in the boat are.  A tape measure and digital camera are invaluable here.

The load water line is marked on the transom.  Do you think this boat had some leaking issues around the transom?
The load water line is marked on the transom. Do you think this boat had some leaking issues around the transom?

 

 

 

Some of the key design lines are easily marked on the boat with a pencil.  Look closely in the picture here to see where I’ve marked the load water line.

 

 

 

 

Finally, I needed to add a walkway to either side of my rack so I would have someplace to stand while I work on the hull.  I was hoping to be able to work from the shop floor, but I need to be able to reach the center of the hull while putting substantial leverage and/or weight on a tool.  Hence the scaffolding addition.

Scaffolding walkways make it easier to reach the center of the bottom with tools.
Scaffolding walkways make it easier to reach the center of the bottom with tools.

Armed with a good platform to work from and a good knowledge of where the boat is out of true, it’s time to take the bottom off.  That’s a story for another day…

Roll Her Over

Once the boat is stripped of as much weight as possible (seats, ceiling, floorboards, engine, instruments, dashboard, rudder, fuel tank, other miscellaneous hardware), it’s time to roll it over.  Much of the work will be done with the boat upside down.  So you’ve got to figure out a way to get this thing upside down without damaging it.

Of course there’s always the “15 Friends and a Mattress” technique.  But I don’t have 15 friends that will agree to show up at the same time to roll a boat over.  And boats are made to be slick and smooth so they can mover through the water.  This makes them difficult to hold on to, particularly when you’re trying not to drop it!  I decided to employ the much safer method of using 2 gantry cranes and an iron pipe.

Rack
1. Rack with crossmembers placed at same interval as frames in the boat

The first step was to make a rack to put the flipped boat on.  It’s a good idea to put casters on the rack, so you can easily move it around your shop.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

2013-02-11 Flip1
2. Morgan Houtz helps with the Rollover. Note the load straps tied over the pipe which is suspended in bearings from the gantry cranes.
2013-02-11 Flip2
3. The boat is picked up with the load straps by raising the pipe.
2013-02-11 Flip3
4. The boat is lowered to the ground so the load straps can be re-tied with less slack in them.
2013-02-11 Flip4
5. Raise the boat and roll the rack into place.
2013-02-11 Flip5
6. Lower the boat onto the rack
2013-02-13 Flip6
7. Sadie the Wonderdog inspects the operation.
2013-02-13 Flip7
8. The boat is rolled out from under the gantry cranes…
2013-02-13 Flip8
9. And into it’s final resting place on the shop floor. Sadie the Wonderdog approves.

Next, I suspended the boat by 2 four-inch load straps that were tied over a 2 inch black iron pipe suspended in a couple of bearing assemblies that my friends at a local machine shop fabricated for me.  The idea is that the pipe with the load straps will rotate in place, allowing you to roll the boat over while it’s hanging from the straps.

Next, I had to lower the boat and re-tie my load straps so I could raise the boat high enough to roll my rack up under it.

Then lower the boat onto the rack.  The cross-spalls on the rack were set at the right height so that when the top of the stringers were set down on them, the boat was level and plumb.  This is the kind of thing you can only pre-plan if you have a copy of the lines drawings.  See the previous post entitled “Plans”.

Then it was a simple matter to roll the rack into place on the shop floor.  Then the rack was blocked up to make it level and plumb.

Special thanks to Morgan Houtz who helped with the roll over, and Sadie the Wonderdog, who helps with everything.

Add an Oil Filter

Oil Filter and Oil Cooler
Oil Filter and Oil Cooler

Back in 1949, Chris Craft did not include an oil filter on their engines.  My research revealed that an internal Chris Craft memo said they expected the engine to outlast the hull, so they decided an oil filter was unnecessary.  This might strike you as odd especially since the engine shares its oil with the transmission.  I certainly found the engine to be very gunky when I took it apart.  I used up ALOT of de-greaser cleaning the inside of this engine!  There were more deposits than I’ve seen before.

Now the old advice not to use high-detergent oil in an old engine makes sense.  I could just see that detergent knocking a blob of gunk loose that would clog a small oil passage somewhere.  Better by far to, as the Beatles say, just “let it be” and hope that gunk stays put.

But since I had it apart and was able to clean it, I decided that I could not in good conscience put this engine back in without an oil filter.  That required fabricating a mounting bracket and finding a place to stick it, and adding plumbing lines to get it into the flow.  I plumbed it so that the oil passes first through the filter, then the oil cooler, then back into the engine.  As you can see from the photo, I mounted it at the rear of the engine, next to the oil cooler.  It will be easy to service here.

We still won’t be using high detergent oil though.  That would interfere with the operation of the reverse gear, which as I said, gets its lubrication from the engine oil.  We’ll use straight weight SAE 30, or SAE 40 depending on where the boat ends up.

Rebuilding the Engine

Tim painting engineI had originally intended to have someone else rebuild the engine.  I was going to open it up to make an assessment of how much of a rebuild was needed, and once I got it apart, I found that it was in pretty good shape.  Re-boring would not be necessary,  and valve clearances appeared to be good–no major wear on the lobes of the camshaft. The crankshaft was in good shape and did not need machining.  So I decided to handle it myself.  I don’t have the machinery to do serious machining, but I can handle a moderate rebuild.

2012-09-13 crankshaft
Crankshaft
Piston heads and valves
Piston heads and valves
2012-09-13 connecting rods
Connecting Rods from below
2012-04-26_engine id plate2
Engine ID Plate

The engine for the boat is the original Chris Craft K engine.  It bears the number shown on the hull card for the boat that I got from the Maritime Museum (see previous post).   The engine block– a flat-head 6 cylinder, was built by the Hercules Truck Company, and Chris Craft marinized it by adding their own manifold, and some other pieces.  It is a 95 hp hunk of cast iron that weighs in at 660 lbs.  In 1949, they weren’t doing a lot of pressed steel, so even the oil pan on this engine is cast iron.  It has a single barrel up-draft carburetor, naturally aspirated.

2012-04-19_engine out stbd fwd
Engine before starting the rebuild–I have no idea why it’s painted Chevy Orange!

The rebuild involved tearing it down to see what kind of shape the bearings, crank, pistons and cylinders were in.  The word I got from the previous owner was that he had fired his mechanic in the middle of rebuilding the engine and some one else had put it back together.  This is never good news.  I wanted to make sure there were no critical missing parts (like bearings!) and see just what needed to be done to get this baby running again.

Probing engineFirst things first–I ran a compression test on the engine before opening it up.  It had oil in it, and it was dirty, so it had be run.  But I wasn’t going to risk running it without seeing the inside first.  The compression test results were good–all cylinders within 12 psi of each other and around 125-135 psi with no significant leakdown.  The bearings and tolerances were in reasonably good shape, but were replaced since I had torn the engine down to that level anyway.  Many of the ancillary pieces such as the  ignition coil, and distributor had to be replaced.  There was no one to rebuild the existing water pump (a brass gear pump), and an impeller pump was a better alternative for a raw water pump anyway.  Both the generator (not alternator) and the starter motor were shipped out to be rebuilt and converted from 6 volt to 12 volt systems.  Also, I rebuilt the original updraft carburetor.

Stay tuned for a short video of the first running of the engine.